Pizza Restaurant locations near Lancaster, OH

Showing 1–10 of 11 results

Lancaster, OH has 11 pizza restaurant listings in our directory. Details on this page were last refreshed Oct 2026.

Updated Oct 2026

Fat Cat Pizza

Pizza Restaurant ⭐ 1.0

📍 1415 Sheridan Dr, Lancaster, OH, 43130

📞 740-652-1111

Fat Cat Pizza is a pizza restaurant located in Lancaster, Ohio, offering dine-in seating and a party room. The menu features a variety of Italian dishes, including different types of pizza, sandwiches like ham and cheese, turkey club, and veggie options. Despite its offerings, the restaurant currently has low customer ratings, indicating potential areas for improvement.

Updated Sep 2026

Cristy's Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

📍 914 N Pierce Ave, Lancaster, OH, 43130

📞 740-653-8106

🌐 cristyspizza.com

Updated Sep 2026

Cristy's Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

📍 1436 Tiki Ln, Lancaster, OH, 43130

📞 740-687-0770

🌐 cristyspizza.com

Updated Aug 2026

Domino's Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

📍 620 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH, 43130

📞 740-654-1300

🌐 www.dominos.com?utm_source=local&utm_medium=organic&utm_content=02204&utm_campaign=localmaps

Founded as a single store in 1960, Domino's Pizza today stands as the recognized world leader in pizza delivery.

Fat Cat Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

📍 323 Washington Ave, Lancaster, OH, 43130

📞 740-687-1966

Fat Cat Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

📍 1448 Ety Pointe Dr Nw, Lancaster, OH, 43130

📞 740-652-1111

🌐 fatcatspizzeria.com

Massey's Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

📍 1229 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH, 43130

📞 740-653-6633

This tradition of excellence still guides the company today. If you consider yourself a connoisseur of great pizza or just a serious pizza lover, you owe it to yourself to try world famous Massey's Pizza. The difference is dramatic! That's why Massey's is known as "The Cadillac of Pizza". Serving Central Ohio since 1949!