Car Auto Insurance locations near Fayette, NY

Showing 1–5 of 5 results

We track 5 car auto insurance listings in and around Fayette, NY, spread over 3 ZIP codes. Listings here were last checked in Jul 2026.

Finger Lakes Partners LLC

📍 62 Reed St, Geneva, NY, 14456

📞 315-789-0700

Finger Lakes Partners LLC, an independent insurance agency with offices in Geneva and Waterloo was formed in September of 2007. Whether it's your first car, second home or third child, we can recommend the coverage that best utilizes and protects your assets. We can help you develop a personal insurance plan to protect the people you care about and give you peace of mind. Our goal is to provide you with adequate insurance at a competitive price. Call us today for more information.

Allstate

📍 143 Fall St, Seneca Falls, NY, 13148

📞 315-568-6348

Updated Jul 2026

RP Wheeler Insurance Agency

📍 790 Pre Emption Rd, Geneva, NY, 14456

📞 315-789-0001

🌐 erieinsurance.com

R. G. Wright Agency Inc.

📍 6369 Half Acre Rd, Auburn, NY, 13021

📞 315-252-7561

Affordable Auto Insurance

📍 155 State St, Auburn, NY, 13021

📞 315-282-2282