Car Auto Insurance locations near New Paltz, NY

Showing 1–10 of 10 results

New Paltz, NY has 10 car auto insurance listings across 4 ZIP codes. Details on this page were last refreshed Aug 2026.

Fox Insurance Agency

📍 82 Vineyard Ave, Highland, NY, 12528

📞 845-691-6600

We are a full service insurance agency specializing in auto insurance, home insurance, contractors insurance, motorcycle insurance, commercial auto insurance, business insurance.. We pride ourselves on good customer service. We service Poughkeepsie, Kingston, New Paltz, Newburgh, Wappingers Falls, Highland, Middletown.

Updated Aug 2026

Naccarato Insurance

📍 108 Main St Ste 1, New Paltz, NY, 12561

📞 845-255-5715

🌐 progressive.com

Naccarato Insurance

📍 Serving Your Area, New Paltz, NY, 12561

📞 845-255-5129

🌐 naccaratoinsurance.com

The Devine Agency Inc.

📍 58 N Chestnut St, New Paltz, NY, 12561

📞 845-255-7806

🌐 devinelnsurance.com

Alianza Auto & Truck Insurance Group

📍 171 Main St, New Paltz, NY, 12561

📞 845-564-1234

🌐 winsurance.com

Allstate

📍 Serving Your Area, Highland, NY, 12528

📞 845-691-4933

Allstate

📍 58 Milton Ave, Highland, NY, 12528

📞 845-691-4904

Tozzi Denise INS

📍 58 Milton Ave, Highland, NY, 12528

📞 845-691-4904

🌐 allstate.com

Freeway Insurance Services

📍 220 Main St, Poughkeepsie, NY, 12601

📞 845-452-1431

Allstate

📍 4285 Albany Post Rd Ste 3, Hyde Park, NY, 12538

📞 845-229-6021